Minority Report

May 16, 2007

Reading:

Started on February 7, 2005. Actually, read in one day, in about an hour and a half.

Specs:

Dick, Philip K., Minority Report, published by Pontheon Books (copyright by Random House) in New York in 2002. The story was written sometime in the early 1950's. Finding information about this book was very difficult because of the strange format of the book.

Overview:

This book is similar to the movie only in that there is a department of precrime, and precogs. In the book the precogs are idiot sevants, and many exist. However, three are required by the police for homocide.

The chief of police, who is on the verge of retiring, is presented with a card (they use cards, not balls) indicating he is going to murder someone. It is not anyone he knows.

Being made aware of the murder, he runs. He is assisted by an unknown person, who claims his wife and the new commissioner set him up. He steals back into the precogs, and gets the original tapes, and discovers there is a minority report. In addition, there are major discrepancies in the two majority reports.

When the man assisting him tries to kill his wife, he decides he's lying, and knocks him senseless. Then he discovers he works for the man he is supposed to kill, who is out to discredit the police.

In fact, there are three minority reports. The first says he will kill the guy, an ex-army general who is trying to establish martial law, when he first learns of him. The second, taking the first into account, says that since he knows the first report exists he will specifically not kill the guy. The third takes into account the first two, and says he will kill him in order to prevent the discrediting of the system. It is correct, as the general reads the three reports in public, realizing too late that the police chief has a gun, as the report indicates, and will kill him.

It is interesting in that it presents a paradox: if the protagonist knows he will kill, then he won't, but if he knows he won't he will to prevent the police from being discredited.


Contact the Author